If the runner on second has a take sign while the third baseman is playing up, what action should the runner take?

If the runner on second has a take sign while the third baseman is playing up, what action should the runner take?

• A. Stay on the base
• B. Run back to first
• C. Steal third base
• D. Attempt to sacrifice bunt

Answer: (C)

When the runner on second is given a take sign, it typically means they are instructed to refrain from stealing or attempting to advance unless it is a clear opportunity. However, in this scenario where the third baseman is playing up (closer to the batter), it creates a unique opportunity. If the runner on second steals third base while the third baseman is positioned closer to the infield, it can catch the defense off guard. The distance the third baseman has to cover to make a play on the runner is increased, potentially leading to a successful steal. Therefore, the runner’s best action in this situation is indeed to steal third base, taking advantage of the defensive alignment. This strategy leverages the element of surprise against the defense, especially when they are less likely to expect a base running move. In this context, staying on the base or running back to first would not be strategic as those actions would not capitalize on the defensive player's positioning. Attempting to sacrifice bunt would also not be appropriate, as the runner on second is typically looking to advance to the next base, not relying on a play that involves the batter sacrificing themselves. Thus, the decision to steal third is strategically sound given the circumstances.

When the runner on second is given a take sign, it typically means they are instructed to refrain from stealing or attempting to advance unless it is a clear opportunity. However, in this scenario where the third baseman is playing up (closer to the batter), it creates a unique opportunity.

If the runner on second steals third base while the third baseman is positioned closer to the infield, it can catch the defense off guard. The distance the third baseman has to cover to make a play on the runner is increased, potentially leading to a successful steal. Therefore, the runner’s best action in this situation is indeed to steal third base, taking advantage of the defensive alignment. This strategy leverages the element of surprise against the defense, especially when they are less likely to expect a base running move.

In this context, staying on the base or running back to first would not be strategic as those actions would not capitalize on the defensive player's positioning. Attempting to sacrifice bunt would also not be appropriate, as the runner on second is typically looking to advance to the next base, not relying on a play that involves the batter sacrificing themselves. Thus, the decision to steal third is strategically sound given the circumstances.